Editor's Choice - Our Favorite Cannister Aquarium Filters

1. Penn Plax Cascade Pro-Carb Canister Filter for Aquariums, 8 Total Filters (4 packs with 2 filters in...

Penn-Plax First Impressions

"Kudos to Amazon prime!"

The filter stopped working all of a sudden. This filter has is a very simple and efficient design. I took it apart reassemble it and it's not pumping in the water. Overall, I'm very happy with this filter. I attempted to clean and lube the impeller, but to no avail. I will never buy any other HOB no matter what deal they might be offering. Fill up the media slot with water until it's full.

  • Penn Plax Cascade Pro-Carb Canister Filter for Aquariums, 8 Total Filters (4 packs with 2 filters in each pack)
  • 8 Total Filters (4 packs with 2 filters in each pack)
  • Convenient, ready-to-use filter bags for use with your Cascade cannister filter
  • Contains carbon & ammonia removing zeolite crystals
  • Filter media fully enclosed in a disposable nylon-mesh bag
  • Manufacture: Penn Plax
  • Product Dimensions: 7.5 x 5 x 2.5 inches; 1.2 Pounds
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Penn-Plax
  • Filter Effectiveness [star rating='4.3']
  • Quality [star rating='4.5']
  • Value For Money [star rating='4.8']
  • Affordability [star rating='5']

Penn-Plax Final Thoughts

"I'd recommend it."

Overall, I like the 350's slim back design, and be able to add up to 4 cartridges. There is a sound from the water shooting into the tank! I was worried that it might be too much for my aquarium or that it would be loud. They were great to deal with and the new filter is working great! I checked and cleaned it and still just as loud. Now I'm having the same issue with the Aqua Clear 50. What I don't like is how much smaller it is than the Aqueon.

Overall Score
5.0

[star rating="5"]
(2 Points)

2. Thanger Submersible Water Pump with Filters 15 Watt, Fountain Pump 400 Gallons per Hour Aquarium Air...

User Ratings: 56 7

Thanger First Impressions

"Hopefully it lasts."

BUT after some YouTube research I was able to fix the noise issue. Once I found that, the world was right again. Replace activated carbon every 6-8 months ish. I used a small pair of pliers and carefully got the pebbles out. The only thing you hear is the water and even that is a soothing sound. This is not my first experience with a marineland filter. I ordered 4 of these, for different tanks of course.

  • Thanger Submersible Water Pump with Filters 15 Watt, Fountain Pump 400 Gallons per Hour Aquarium Air Pump, Underwater Cleaner Oxygen Charging Wave Maker for Fish Turtle Tanks, Ponds, Pool, Waterfall
  • ULTRA QUIET DESIGN & PERFECT MOTOR - The reliable and duarable copper wire motor does not produce much noise, giving you quiet environment. It can elevate column of water up to 5.25ft ( 1.6 meters)
  • TWO FILTER NETS & EASY TO CLEAN - The pump has two filter nets, which can effectively filter large blocks during pumping to prevent blockage, and effectively improve the circulation system to maintain a clean water environment. No need any tools to detach it, easy to seperate, easy to clean.
  • MULTIPLE WATER NOZZLES & ADJUSTABLE FLOW RATE - Equipped with two water nozzles (1.3cm/1.6cm) and one boost oxygen nozzle along with boost hose. The adjustable knob allows to adjust the water flow rate, and the maximal flow rate can be up to 400GPH(1500L/H).
  • STRONG SUCTION CUP & 1.6M POWER CORD - There are four strong suction cup at the bottom of the small pump that fits well on a horizontal or vertical glass surface to keep the pump running smoothly. The power cord is 1.6 meters, which is long enough for installation depending on your needs.
  • WIDE APPLICATIONS - The filter water pump has a wide range of applications that it can be used in aquariums, ecological tanks, breeding ponds, landscape tubes, gardens, rockery fountains, etc.
  • 0.51 inches / 1.3cm water nozzle
  • 0.63 inches / 1.6cm water nozzle
  • Boost oxygen water nozzle
  • Manufacture: Thanger
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Thanger
  • Filter Effectiveness [star rating='5']
  • Quality [star rating='3.6']
  • Value For Money [star rating='4.8']
  • Affordability [star rating='4.1']

Thanger Final Thoughts

"Disappointing."

I'm currently in the process of receiving another replacement on that model. Once it loses its charge, you'll need to replace it. Overall, I'm very happy with this filter. I still have my original wheels on the year old 350 with no issues whatsoever. I had to lower the surface by 3 inches to get sufficient agitation. I have always used Marineland filters and been happy with them and their quality. I used a small pair of pliers and carefully got the pebbles out.

Overall Score
4.1

[star rating="4.1"]
(111 Points)

3. WUPYI Aquarium External Filter Fish Tank External Filter Box Aquarium Filter Fish Tank Upper Trickle...

User Ratings: 82

WUPYI First Impressions

"No worries there."

Also price was very reasonable and shipping was fast. I have 4 other AquaClear filters and like them. Once it loses its charge, you'll need to replace it. I decided to go with this filter since I had a positive experience previously. Fill up the media slot with water until it's full. My tank was a mess when I got this pump. I've think I've had had six of them.

  • WUPYI Aquarium External Filter Fish Tank External Filter Box Aquarium Filter Fish Tank Upper Trickle Box Filters System 6-Drawer,Transparent
  • ★360 degree loop rain design, the flow rate is not fast, not sparse, the filter material is fully water, the dissolved oxygen is more sufficient, and the culture is more effective.
  • ★The scientific design of the 360 degree loop tube can effectively use the water flow to achieve a uniform drip effect, which can achieve the perfect balance between energy saving and dripping effect.
  • ★One-piece molding, the box truly "anti-overflow".Easy to clean and Change material, just open the box and change the filter material when needed
  • ★Plastic steel strengthens the bottom plate, which can bear the weight of 160 kg of solid plastic material base. It is not easy to deform and not bend when subjected to large gravity.
  • ★Guarantee the quality is the basic rule.WUPYI is dedicated to providing quality services, quality products and fast delivery(US WAREHOUSE). Any question,please contact us.
  • Manufacture: WUPYI
  • Editor's Impressions Of The WUPYI
  • Filter Effectiveness [star rating='5']
  • Quality [star rating='4.5']
  • Value For Money [star rating='4.9']
  • Affordability [star rating='5']

WUPYI Final Thoughts

"+Great price."

This filter has is a very simple and efficient design. Not sure what I'll do with the more complex design. There is a sound from the water shooting into the tank! I had a lot of particles in the water. My fish are definitely happier and my water is crystal clear. That water got so dirty we had to keep changing it every 2 or 3 days. Firstly, I'd recommend taking the motor apart and putting it back together.

Overall Score
4.8

[star rating="4.8"]
(9 Points)

4. hygger Super Mini Aquarium Single Sponge Filter, Comes with 1 Spare Sponge, Quiet Submersible Foam F...

User Ratings: 55 9

hygger First Impressions

"I bought this filter."

I had originally got one for my 75 Gallon tank housing an Oscar. SO I decided to order this for my 29 gallon tank. Works like a dream and can't even hear it! It wasn't producing much surface agitation. This is not my first experience with a marineland filter. You'll want to pull that water from the bottom. This filter has is a very simple and efficient design.

  • hygger Super Mini Aquarium Single Sponge Filter, Comes with 1 Spare Sponge, Quiet Submersible Foam Filter for Small Fish Tank 0.5-5 Gallon
  • 【Multi-filtration functions】this mini sponge aquarium filter combines bio-filtration, oxygenation and physical filtration in one and also makes small water flow, which can ensure the excellence of the water quality. Helps your small fish or shrimp to live a happy, healthy life
  • 【Super Mini Filter Demension 】this single sponge filter is super mini size, takes up a little room, perfect for use in 0.5-5 gallon fish tank bowls. This mini sponge filter is 3.5" in width and 3" in height, the sponge inside circle diameter is 0.59 inch
  • 【Package Includes】1 single mini sponge filter + 1 spare sponge+ 1 suction cup are included in a pack. This aquarium filter must be used with an mini air pupm and a standard size 4mm air hose, please note pump and air hose, media balls are not included. Please choose an air pump according to your fish tank size for this filter
  • 【Removable Fine Sponges 】you can easy to take down the sponge from the filter to clean or replace it, the sponge is fine not coarse, which means more surface area for beneficial bacteri to live on. Don't use tap water to clean it, just rinse or squeeze the sponges by using the aquarium water
  • 【Easy to use】all the parts of this filter are detachable, you can easily to assemble them together, with 1 strong suction cup you can stick the filter firmly to any tank position under water, withouting floating.
  • Manufacture: hygger
  • Editor's Impressions Of The hygger
  • Filter Effectiveness [star rating='4.5']
  • Quality [star rating='3.7']
  • Value For Money [star rating='3.7']
  • Affordability [star rating='4.2']

hygger Final Thoughts

"A THUMBS UP."

I liked the clean lined look and the pull out basket. All in all, I highly recommend this filter and I'm a extremely happy customer! I put it together, reading instructions of course. I returned the Aqua Clear 70 and promptly received a replacement. BUT after some YouTube research I was able to fix the noise issue. I used a small pair of pliers and carefully got the pebbles out. Works like a dream and can't even hear it!

Overall Score
4.0

[star rating="4"]
(486 Points)

5. hygger Aquarium Single Sponge Filter, Comes with 1 Spare Sponges, Quiet Submersible Foam Corner Filt...

User Ratings: 70 2

hygger First Impressions

"This is the one."

I DONT KNOW WHY MANY THINK THIS IS A NOISY FILTER. It's easy to clean and we all know about easy. It started out silent for about 30 mins and then it got super loud. First they are simple and designed to pump and filter aquarium water. I also don't like how short the intake tube is. I was using a Tetra in-tank filter previously. I bought a top fin 55 gallon aquarium on sale.

  • hygger Aquarium Single Sponge Filter, Comes with 1 Spare Sponges, Quiet Submersible Foam Corner Filter for Small Fish Tank 5-15 Gallon
  • 【Multi-filtration functions】this sponge aquarium filter combines bio-filtration, oxygenation and physical filtration in one and also makes small water flow, which can ensure the excellence of the water quality. Helps your small fish or shrimp to live a happy, healthy life
  • 【Single Filter Demension 】this single sponge filter takes up no more room, perfect for use in 5-15 gallon fish tank. This small filter is 3.7" in width and 7.5" to 10.6" in height, the sponge inside circle diameter is 0.39 inch
  • 【Package Includes】1 single sponge filter + 1 spare sponge+ 2 suction cups are included in a pack. This aquarium filter must be used with an air pupm and a standard size 4mm air hose, please note pump, media balls and air hose are not included. Please choose an air pump according to your fish tank size for this filter
  • 【Removable Fine Sponges 】you can easy to take down the sponge from the filter to clean or replace it, the sponge is fine not coarse, which means more surface area for beneficial bacteri to live on. Don't use tap water to clean it, just rinse or squeeze the sponges by using the aquarium water
  • 【Easy to use】all the parts of this filter are detachable, you can easily to assemble them together, with 2 strong suction cups you can stick the filter firmly to any tank position under water, withouting floating. The water oulet tube can be extended and rotated, you can adjust the outlet to above or below the waterline
  • Manufacture: hygger
  • Editor's Impressions Of The hygger
  • Filter Effectiveness [star rating='3.7']
  • Quality [star rating='4.6']
  • Value For Money [star rating='3.9']
  • Affordability [star rating='3.6']

hygger Final Thoughts

"Its AMAZING."

It wasn't producing much surface agitation. Fill it up with water before you plug it in. I'd highly recommend not replacing the bio material& sponge, ever. Of course the sound all depends on how much water is in the aquarium. As for performance, I couldn't ask for a better filter. As for performance, I couldn't ask for a better filter. Unlike my old HOB filter, it doesn't sound like a leaky toilet.

Overall Score
4.5

[star rating="4.5"]
(92 Points)

6. Ultum Nature Systems Delta Aquarium Tank Canister Filter

User Ratings: 92

Ultum Nature Systems First Impressions

"29 gallons."

Now I'm having the same issue with the Aqua Clear 50. This is not my first experience with a marineland filter. Controlling the flow rate doesn't require modifying the filter. First they are simple and designed to pump and filter aquarium water. Not sure what I'll do with the more complex design. A canister or in tank filter is ten times more work and messy. As for performance, I couldn't ask for a better filter.

  • Ultum Nature Systems Delta Aquarium Tank Canister Filter
  • Suitable for freshwater and marine aquariums
  • AC110V 60HZ, Max Flow Rate: 350G/HR
  • Includes filter media, tubing, and inflow outflow fittings
  • Dimensions: 9.65 x 8.7 x 14.4"
  • Usage: Up to 92 gallons
  • Manufacture: Ultum Nature Systems
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Ultum Nature Systems
  • Filter Effectiveness [star rating='4.8']
  • Quality [star rating='5']
  • Value For Money [star rating='4.5']
  • Affordability [star rating='4']

Ultum Nature Systems Final Thoughts

"This one does!"

I DONT KNOW WHY MANY THINK THIS IS A NOISY FILTER. I can hear it 3 rooms away grinding away. I was using a Tetra in-tank filter previously. If that does not work, look into silicone grease so you can lube the impeller. My tank is nice and clear and my fish are much happier. I returned the Aqua Clear 70 and promptly received a replacement. This new AQ50 filter has loose bio-media, i.

Overall Score
4.9

[star rating="4.9"]
(18 Points)

7. Think Crucial Aquarium Filter Replacement Parts - Compatible with Aqua-Tech EZ-Change 3 Aquarium Fil...

User Ratings: 70 5

Think Crucial 20-40 Power Filters, 30-60 Power Filters First Impressions

"Canisters don't."

I will never buy any other HOB no matter what deal they might be offering. They are easily found from mom-n-pop pet stores to large chain stores. You do have to unplug it for those two jobs. If that does not work, look into silicone grease so you can lube the impeller. One thing I think is worth mentioning is the need to prime the filter. Of course the sound all depends on how much water is in the aquarium. I will never buy any other HOB no matter what deal they might be offering.

  • Think Crucial Aquarium Filter Replacement Parts - Compatible with Aqua-Tech EZ-Change 3 Aquarium Filter - Fits Aqua-Tech 20-40 and 30-60 Power Filters
  • 4 PACK OF AQUARIUM FILTER REPLACEMENTS COMPATIBLE WITH AQUA-TECH EZ-CHANGE 3 AQUARIUM FILTER. Filters are essential for premium aquarium air quality and cleaner air. They trap fine dust particles and allergens, preventing them from recirculating. Helps keep your tank free of dust, with frequent filter replacement.
  • CLEAN AND HEALTHY LIFESTYLE: Replacing Aqua-Tech filters should help clean with premium filtration for healthier fish. The aquarium filter screens out dirt and debris. The molded ribbed back has maximum water-to-carbon contact. The filter removes odors, discolorations, and impurities. Change the used filter monthly. Ensure elimination of toxic ammonia and nitrite while avoiding clogging.
  • SIMPLE AND EASY TO INSTALL: Switch out in less than five (5) minutes, providing time efficiency. Our aquarium filter measures 4.5" X 6" X 6.5" inches. Get back to daily activity quickly and make a big difference with filtration in the process. Simply remove the older and dirty filter and replace. It fits well with Aqua-Tech aquarium filter cartridge. Enjoy a clean, fresh, aquarium for healthier fish by using premium, heavy duty equipment, filters and clean water.
  • LONG LASTING REPLACEMENT AQUARIUM FILTER: The aquarium filter is washable and reusable ensuring long life. Replace the Aqua-Tech filter every 2 to 4 weeks for optimal performance or ten (10) to twelve (12) times per year depending upon usage. When a clogged or dirty, it can cause the aquarium to work harder and impact utility bills. We deliver high quality, durable and long lasting replacements. Aquarium filters are extremely important for your AquaTech filtration system.
  • THINK CRUCIAL manufactures premium quality air filters, purifier parts and stands behind the quality and workmanship of all our products. We maintain a thorough quality control process to ensure compatibility with the Aqua-Tech models listed above.
  • Manufacture: Think Crucial
  • Product Dimensions: 0.98 x 0.98 x 0.98 inches; 7.2 Ounces
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Think Crucial 20-40 Power Filters, 30-60 Power Filters
  • Filter Effectiveness [star rating='4.5']
  • Quality [star rating='4.9']
  • Value For Money [star rating='5']
  • Affordability [star rating='5']

Think Crucial 20-40 Power Filters, 30-60 Power Filters Final Thoughts

"Its AMAZING."

This is not my first experience with a marineland filter. I've think I've had had six of them. First they are simple and designed to pump and filter aquarium water. I can take apart a car engine and put it back together. I want to answer some of the complaints I've read. You do have to unplug it for those two jobs. My tank is nice and clear and my fish are much happier.

Overall Score
4.4

[star rating="4.4"]
(671 Points)

8. Fluval 107 Perfomance Canister Filter

User Ratings: 72 8

Fluval A440 First Impressions

"Not ideal but it works."

It wasn't producing much surface agitation. It wasn't producing much surface agitation. Unlike my old HOB filter, it doesn't sound like a leaky toilet. All in all, I highly recommend this filter and I'm a extremely happy customer! I'd highly recommend not replacing the bio material& sponge, ever. Overall I would recommend this item. Your fish and you will be much happier and stun everyone else.

  • Fluval 107 Perfomance Canister Filter
  • Ergonomic design and raised lip for smoother operation
  • Single action dual locking clamps for quick release & attachment
  • New center handle allows Main media stack to be removed
  • Redesigned system – requires less pumps to engage
  • The all-new 07 series marks the 7th incarnation in nearly 4 decades of fluval’s top selling canister Filter family Worldwide. Not only does the latest generation incorporate the power and reliability you’ve come to expect from the leader in aquatic filtration, but it also features several new performance upgrades that make it up to 25% quieter and more robust, energy-efficient, flexible and easier to use than ever before
  • Manufacture: Hagen
  • Item Weight: 2.2 pounds
  • Product Dimensions: 0.39 x 0.39 x 0.39 inches
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Fluval A440
  • Filter Effectiveness [star rating='3.6']
  • Quality [star rating='3.9']
  • Value For Money [star rating='3.8']
  • Affordability [star rating='3.9']

Fluval A440 Final Thoughts

"A few tips."

I had a lot of particles in the water. You'll want to pull that water from the bottom. Works like a dream and can't even hear it! They are simply the best design for nitrifying bacteria to grow on. Lift the sticking wheel outuse a Q-tip to clean the slots where the wheel rests. My baby turtle even loves it so much he won't let go. I wasn't able to fill my tank fully because there was little to no surface agitation.

Overall Score
4.4

[star rating="4.4"]
(279 Points)

9. Aqua Flo 14" Pond & Aquarium Filter Media, 72" (6 Feet) Long x 1" Thick (Pink/White)

User Ratings: 67

Aqua Flo 14x120Pink First Impressions

"No worries there."

This is a well designed unit and a lot of bang for the buck. Once I found that, the world was right again. I was new to the hobby and didn't realize that Tetras were inferior filters. The instructions are a bit to much for me. It was perfectly quiet without any extra effort on my part. Fill it up with water before you plug it in. I was worried about some of the negative reviews.

  • Aqua Flo 14" Pond & Aquarium Filter Media, 72" (6 Feet) Long x 1" Thick (Pink/White)
  • Over 30 years of proven customer satisfaction with our pink filter product.
  • No chemicals used in production! Safe for all fresh or saltwater fish, tanks & ponds.
  • Easy to cut with scissors to any size needed.
  • Proudly Made in the USA by an American Company
  • Manufacture: Aqua-Flo Industries
  • Item Weight: 2.39 ounces
  • Product Dimensions: 72 x 14 x 1 inches
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Aqua Flo 14x120Pink
  • Filter Effectiveness [star rating='3.9']
  • Quality [star rating='5']
  • Value For Money [star rating='4.1']
  • Affordability [star rating='5']

Aqua Flo 14x120Pink Final Thoughts

"Yeah, no no no!"

There is a sound from the water shooting into the tank! There must be a huge batch of these units at Amazon right now that are bad. Not sure what I'll do with the more complex design. They can be very noisy at the impeller, which sometimes quiets in time, but may not. DO NOT CLEAN OR WASH the paper wheel itself. This lives up to the praise that people give it. A canister or in tank filter is ten times more work and messy.

Overall Score
4.0

[star rating="4"]
(5 Points)

10. Powkoo Fish Tank Filter Pad, Bio Sponge Filter Media Pad, Cut-to-Size Foam for Aquarium Fish Tank Po...

User Ratings: 82

Powkoo First Impressions

"Canisters don't."

Months later, this filter is still working great on my 29 gal set up. I attempted to clean and lube the impeller, but to no avail. I had to cut the hood to make it work. Just rinse them out once a month, don't throw that beneficial bacteria away. This filter has is a very simple and efficient design. You'll want to pull that water from the bottom. Typically just below the flat part of the outlets.

  • Powkoo Fish Tank Filter Pad, Bio Sponge Filter Media Pad, Cut-to-Size Foam for Aquarium Fish Tank Pond
  • Powkoo sponge filter pad provide both mechanical and biological filtration, perfect for freshwater or saltwater aquariums
  • Size: 17.7" L x 17.7" W x 1.97" H(30PPI); Cut-To-Size filter media bio sponge, aquarium filter pads can easily be cut to fit most filters
  • Offers more surface area for water filter and improve water quality, trap floating debris to help keep your aquarium water crystal clear, and will not get clogged easily
  • Place our aquarium filter pad in flowing water to trap uneaten food, waste, decaying plants, detritus, and other coarse to small floating particulates from the water
  • Powkoo aquarium filter floss pad, durable and reusable, cut to fit, very good flow, easy to clean, perfect for filtering your aquarium fish tank pond
  • Manufacture: Powkoo
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Powkoo
  • Filter Effectiveness [star rating='5']
  • Quality [star rating='5']
  • Value For Money [star rating='4.6']
  • Affordability [star rating='5']

Powkoo Final Thoughts

"No big deal."

In the afternoon the noises started again. Overall, I'm very happy with this filter. Controlling the flow rate doesn't require modifying the filter. This filter really does a good job. I will pick 3-4 of these at one time over a single system any day. I eyedball everything and put it together with a look back at instructions. SO I decided to order this for my 29 gallon tank.

Overall Score
4.8

[star rating="4.8"]
(40 Points)

Copyright © 2024 Rob Aquatics — Primer Child WordPress theme by GoDaddy