Editor's Choice - Our Favorite Hidom Fish Breeding Tanks

1. Hidom Floating Fish Aquarium Hatchery Breeding and Parenting Box with Live Fry Trap

User Ratings: 62 6

Hidom First Impressions

"Good product."

Worked well, water and air flow is minimum due to slots being very thin. I highly recommend this product, simple and easy to use! No more babies swimming back up the cracks and getten eaten by mom. The babies are now in the box without the middle divider piece. I can home one day and one was dead and all torn up from the sides. We have 12 babies swimming around in our tank at the moment. The funnel tray is placed too high within the box.

  • Hidom Floating Fish Aquarium Hatchery Breeding and Parenting Box with Live Fry Trap
  • A safe floating fish haven for livebearing fish and fry.
  • Bottom compartment safely collects and protects falling fry.
  • Includes suction cups, partition and lid.
  • Can also be used for displaying Betta (Siamese Fighting) Fish.
  • Suitable for isolating sick, injured or aggressive fish.
  • Manufacture: Hidom
  • Product Dimensions: 3.94 x 2.76 x 5.12 inches; 3.53 Ounces
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Hidom
  • Quality
  • Value For Money
  • Affordability

Hidom Final Thoughts

"Overall I did like it."

The dividers only work with the fry drop in place. I bought one to try it out, and it's been excellent. Neither ended up having their babies in the breeder box. My kids observe the fish and write notes about health and behavior. Neither ended up having their babies in the breeder box. I rated this 4 because it works great for the babies to live in for a bit. Tired of my guppies eating their fry and found this.

Overall Score
4.1


(106 Points)

Peoples Choice - Other Highly Rated Hidom Fish Breeding Tanks

2. Hidom Fish Aquarium Hatchery Floating Breeding And Parenting Box

User Ratings: 47 16

Hidom First Impressions

"Very easy to assemble."

With the fry drop removed you get a really nice size little tank. I took the out of the tank and put them in mugs but it was not practical. I do suggest leaving the lid above the waterline, however, as it has two holes. Two days later and we have about 20 babies swimming in the bottom part of the box. I'm using it as a nursery for baby guppies. The Petzilla and Lee's make observations easier. I really liked the fact I could add an airline for water flow.

  • Hidom Fish Aquarium Hatchery Floating Breeding And Parenting Box
  • A safe floating fish haven for livebearing fish and fry.
  • Bottom compartment safely collects and protects falling fry.
  • Includes suction cups, partition and lid.
  • Can also be used for displaying Betta (Siamese Fighting) Fish.
  • Suitable for isolating sick, injured or aggressive fish.
  • Manufacture: Hidom
  • Product Dimensions: 5.24 x 2.95 x 2.95 inches; 4.23 Ounces
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Hidom
  • Quality
  • Value For Money
  • Affordability

Hidom Final Thoughts

"Over all pretty good."

If that bottom piece fit better it would have been perfect. The Petzilla and Lee's make observations easier. It's roomy and gives them space to move around. I also like that it goes in to the tank and not a hang on the outside type. It's unsightly with big uneven seams and extra fabric. This is the best floating breeder I have ever tried. That's why I took time to come back.

Overall Score
3.7


(64 Points)

3. Hidom Large Fish Aquarium Hatchery Floating Breeding And Parenting Box - Lenght 205Mm

User Ratings: 60 6

Hidom First Impressions

"This is not a small box."

Lets in just enough new water to keep it clean, but not too much to have a current. I left it out and the babies were sneaking out through that hole. The net is harder to see through but not for the casual observer. The little air tube connection on the side is a nice addition too. I put the rainbar into it so now they can't escape. The dividers only work with the fry drop in place. We picked this up to use as a secondary QT box for our reef tank.

  • Hidom Large Fish Aquarium Hatchery Floating Breeding And Parenting Box - Lenght 205Mm
  • A safe floating fish haven for livebearing fish and fry.
  • Bottom compartment safely collects and protects falling fry.
  • Includes suction cups, partition and lid.
  • Can also be used for displaying Betta (Siamese Fighting) Fish.
  • Suitable for isolating sick, injured or aggressive fish.
  • Manufacture: Hidom
  • Product Dimensions: 8.07 x 3.94 x 3.62 inches; 8.47 Ounces
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Hidom
  • Quality
  • Value For Money
  • Affordability

Hidom Final Thoughts

"It does work."

Worked well, water and air flow is minimum due to slots being very thin. There is a grate that sits about an inch above the bottom of the box. Fits nicely in a size 10 gallon tank. One of them does not because you're supposed to add some sort of water rain bar. It comes with 2 removable dividers and a removable fry drop slotted piece. Apparently my purple Betta, Dragonfruit, did not get the memo. That's why I took time to come back.

Overall Score
4.1


(30 Points)

4. luckycyc Acrylic Reptile Feeding Box,Transparent Reptile Breeding Box Full View Visually Acrylic Sli...

User Ratings: 61

Luckycyc First Impressions

"Works ok for me."

Much easier to use and install than those tank partitions. The net is harder to see through but not for the casual observer. Unlike the males, female Bettas should get along together. It's a decent size for an internal breeder box. We need to do mare to make sure bettas are treated better in pet stores, though. I popped this together in a minute and it was in the tank in another minute. He had room to still swim around and I didn't feel too guilty.

  • luckycyc Acrylic Reptile Feeding Box,Transparent Reptile Breeding Box Full View Visually Acrylic Sliding Cover Type Feeding Box for Insect Reptiles Tarantulas Amphibians(No Pets Included)
  • ♥Secure material: Safe and environmentally friendly materials, creating a warm home for pets.
  • ♥Visible design: 360 degrees completely transparent, clear and bright and easy to observe.
  • ♥Suitable objects: Suitable for spiders, scorpions, horned frogs, beetles, small ornamental snakes, etc.
  • ♥Convenient design: Sliding cover design for easy feeding and care for the pets.
  • ♥Wide application: Stylish appearance that is suitable for a variety of climbing pets.
  • Manufacture: luckycyc
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Luckycyc
  • Quality
  • Value For Money
  • Affordability

Luckycyc Final Thoughts

"Thank you!"

If that bottom piece fit better it would have been perfect. The dimensions for the large size are approximately 8. The little air tube connection on the side is a nice addition too. Kind of a pain to remove the lid and feed the fry. Breeder nets are available in many sizes including larger than both boxes. My husband got me a few guppies that apparently had been pregnant. I use this all the time for fish or new plants.

Overall Score
4.2


(6 Points)

5. fitTek 5 X 50Mm 2" Round Air Stones for Pond Or Aquarium Fish Tank

User Ratings: 61

fitTek First Impressions

"Imperfect design."

I use this all the time for fish or new plants. I've used several other floating breeders, and have always wished they were larger. I feel like this breeder box is sturdier than some others that I've used. It comes with 2 removable dividers and a removable fry drop slotted piece. I am using several to sort through some fish I am breeding. Mine's been doing fine and very useful. I really liked the fact I could add an airline for water flow.

  • fitTek 5 X 50Mm 2" Round Air Stones for Pond Or Aquarium Fish Tank
  • You are purchasing 5 x 50mm (2inch) air stones suitable for aquarium and pond use.
  • These air stones will connect to standard 4/6mm air line. Or, the hose tail can be cut to accommodate thicker air line.
  • Manufacture: fitTek
  • Editor's Impressions Of The fitTek
  • Quality
  • Value For Money
  • Affordability

fitTek Final Thoughts

"Very useful."

We had 2 pregnant fish in seperate halves with them seperated. The breeder box has a decent size for isolating fish or dwarf shrimp. With the fry drop removed you get a really nice size little tank. No more babies swimming back up the cracks and getten eaten by mom. So overall, this is a functioning product with little issues. I left it out and the babies were sneaking out through that hole. I do suggest leaving the lid above the waterline, however, as it has two holes.

Overall Score
4.5


(17 Points)

6. Fish Breeding Box, Aquarium Breeder Box Fish Baby Hatchery Incubator Isolation with Artificial Plant...

User Ratings: 60 6

Tfwadmx First Impressions

"Works ok for me."

It is large enough for fish bigger than guppies. My husband got me a few guppies that apparently had been pregnant. We picked this up to use as a secondary QT box for our reef tank. Good size and I like the separated chambers. With the fry drop in you have plenty of room for temporarily keeping the females. I will definitely buy these kind of breeder again. Guppy fry didn't escape and they look happy.

  • Fish Breeding Box, Aquarium Breeder Box Fish Baby Hatchery Incubator Isolation with Artificial Plant for Guppy
  • ✔PROTECT JUVENILE FISH -- Prevent the baby fish from the adult fish's attack and improve the survival rate of the baby fish. Perfect isolation for aggressive fish, injured fish, small fish, shrimp, clown fish, and other marine fishes.
  • ✔MULTIPLE-ROOM DESIGN -- Multiple rooms Designed Space can be divided into as much as 3 small “rooms” as needed. Remove all the partitions to work as a large hatchery box.
  • ✔EFFECTIVE ISOLATION -- 0.5mm Super-slim Isolation Gap Thinner than the gap of the fish eggs plate, effectively protect the baby fish from the invasion of the adult fish.
  • ✔STABLE WITHOUT FLOATING -- Original Design of 4 stands to Make It Steady The W funnel won't be floating because of the water pressure when it's not placed upright.
  • ✔NOTE -- Please be advised that the clear acrylic pieces come with a protective film on both sides. Please tear it off when you use it.
  • Manufacture: Tfwadmx
  • Item Weight: 14.4 ounces
  • Product Dimensions: 1 x 1 x 1 inches
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Tfwadmx
  • Quality
  • Value For Money
  • Affordability

Tfwadmx Final Thoughts

"This product is great."

The tube for the bubbler is a nice touch. They seemed scared at first but calmed down after about 30 minutes. The suction cups were adequate and held the breeder on to the glass fairly well. If that bottom piece fit better it would have been perfect. I really like the design of this breeder box. It's a decent size for an internal breeder box. The breeder box has a decent size for isolating fish or dwarf shrimp.

Overall Score
4.2


(91 Points)

7. Underwater Treasures Net Breeder Isolation Chamber

User Ratings: 52 48

Underwater Treasures 4450 First Impressions

"Great design."

I have used other breeder boxes and like this one the best. Took me a little while to figure it out but it worked for me. I have both the small and larger version. I do suggest leaving the lid above the waterline, however, as it has two holes. Good size and I like the separated chambers. We caught momma the day before she had them and removed her after. It is large enough for fish bigger than guppies.

  • Underwater Treasures Net Breeder Isolation Chamber
  • This product is easy to use
  • This product adds a great Value
  • This product is Manufactured in China
  • The Package Weight Of The Product Is 4.61 Pounds
  • Manufacture: Underwater Treasures
  • Product Dimensions: 9.3 x 4.6 x 4.5 inches; 5.6 Ounces
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Underwater Treasures 4450
  • Quality
  • Value For Money
  • Affordability

Underwater Treasures 4450 Final Thoughts

"Priced right."

I popped this together in a minute and it was in the tank in another minute. It's unsightly with big uneven seams and extra fabric. Instead of catching babies, I simply leave the mom in the top piece. I really liked the fact I could add an airline for water flow. Future design improvement- less room for fry, more room for moms. I got this so I can just put him in our 20-gallon hex with the angelfish. So far, those have both held up, so the non-locking lid has not been an issue.

Overall Score
3.1


(3 Points)

8. Breeding Box Trap With Circulation System 2l

User Ratings: 70 7

Superfish 545010 First Impressions

"I recommend this box."

With everything out the tank seems to stay really clean. Took me a little while to figure it out but it worked for me. One of them does not because you're supposed to add some sort of water rain bar. They are impossible to reach once it it attached. Not as sturdy as I thought but perfect for what I wanted. With everything out the tank seems to stay really clean. I also like that it goes in to the tank and not a hang on the outside type.

  • Breeding Box Trap With Circulation System 2l
  • High quality item. Genuine product
  • High quality item. Genuine product
  • Description coming soon
  • Manufacture: Superfish
  • Product Dimensions: 4.33 x 4.33 x 4.33 inches; 7.05 Ounces
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Superfish 545010
  • Quality
  • Value For Money
  • Affordability

Superfish 545010 Final Thoughts

"It is perfect!"

My other one was fine but I brought her out so she wouldn't get hurt. This keeps her area better airated and actually helps flow the babies out. I have noticed that with all they pieces in that food does not exit the bottom half. Hope you found this review helpful! I usually wait to write reviews but I am already impressed with this breeding box. It's unsightly with big uneven seams and extra fabric. Took me a little while to figure it out but it worked for me.

Overall Score
4.4


(32 Points)

9. Hmlai Clearance Women Swimdress One Piece Tummy Control Plus Size Sunflower Print Ruched Swimsuit Sh...

Hmlai Clearance First Impressions

"Overall I did like it."

I do suggest leaving the lid above the waterline, however, as it has two holes. I tested both my tank and box water to find a big difference in Ammonia levels. This is my first breeder box so I cant really compare with other brands. I currently have about 30 or so new babies in it. First one arrived used with gravel and a hole in it. They are now all back together, living as peaceably as fish can. I put three pregnant females in the box immediately.

  • Hmlai Clearance Women Swimdress One Piece Tummy Control Plus Size Sunflower Print Ruched Swimsuit Shaping Body Bathing Suits
  • ??swimwear for women plus size swimwear for women one piece sexy tankini tops tankinis swimwear for women swimwear Womens Sexy Plus Size Swimwear Tankini Bikini Two Piece Swimsuit Bathing Suit
  • Imported
  • ??women Swimwear Push-Up Padded Bra Sexy Swimsuit Halter Beachwear One Piece Tankini boyshort Slimming Skirt Swimsuits Halter Underwired Top Vintage Swimsuits Bikinis Bathing Suits Two Piece Beachwear Halter Neck Bathing Suit Swimwear swimwear for women
  • women swimwear one piece tummy control women swimwear one piece sexy women swimwear one piece plus size women swimwear one piece shorts women swimwear plus size women swimwear push up women swimwear pants
  • women swimwear tankini swimsuit women swimwear two piece women swimwear tops only women swimwear tummy control women swimwear two piece set women swimwear tops and bottoms women swimming clothes
  • Athletic Training Swimsuits Swimwear Bathing Suits for Women swimsuit tops for women swimsuit Women's Plus Size Two Piece Tankini Swimwear Swimdress Swimsuits Bathing Suits Sexy Women Bikini Set Swimwear Push-Up Padded Bra Swimsuit Beachwear
  • Women Swimsuit Cross Padded Push up Bikini Set Two Piece Bathing Suits Swimwear Swimsuits swimwear maternity plus size swimwear two piece swimwear tummy control swimwear plus size swimwear bottoms swimwear 2 piece swimwear Women Tankini Sets Shorts
  • Swimsuits for Women Tummy Control Backless Bathing Suits Retro Elastic High Cut Low Back One Piece Swimwear swimsuit for women cute one piece swimsuit for women Sexy One Piece Women Bandage Thong Bikini Swimsuit Swimwear Bathing Beachwear swimsuit bottoms for women
  • Manufacture: Hmlai Clearance
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Hmlai Clearance
  • Quality
  • Value For Money
  • Affordability

Hmlai Clearance Final Thoughts

"Over all pretty good."

They are now all back together, living as peaceably as fish can. Apparently my purple Betta, Dragonfruit, did not get the memo. The breeder box has a decent size for isolating fish or dwarf shrimp. I will update after the babies are born but so far this is great. Worked well, water and air flow is minimum due to slots being very thin. I am using several to sort through some fish I am breeding. The Petzilla and Lee's make observations easier.

Overall Score
5.0


(2 Points)

10. Camidy Cichlids Fish Egg Incubator Acrylic Aquarium Tumbler Incubator Fish Fry Hatchery Eggs Aquariu...

User Ratings: 64 36

Camidy 1450221/120852AM102US68 First Impressions

"Very glad I bought it."

I'll put the bag from the pet shop in it and cut it open. The baby fish were able to swim from the bottom back to the time in the corners. The lid doesn't lock in place too snugly which make it easy to open. I own 7 of these isolation, breeding tanks. I gave 4 stars becauses the mesh gets algae ridden pretty easily and stained green. There's only one issue with this unit. I got this so I can just put him in our 20-gallon hex with the angelfish.

  • Camidy Cichlids Fish Egg Incubator Acrylic Aquarium Tumbler Incubator Fish Fry Hatchery Eggs Aquarium Breeding Mouth-Brooding 40mmx30cm
  • 1. Gas Lift connector bending is more than 90 degrees, the water outlet is smooth, small air pump can drive.
  • 5. Acrylic bracket, convenient to view.
  • 2. Ultra-transparent thickened acrylic hatching tube, smooth cut.
  • 4. Filter cotton using black biochemical cotton, safe, good filter effect.
  • 3. 1mm sieve plate holes, the lower sieve plate is glued in the main incubation room, effectively prevent the escape of fish eggs.
  • Manufacture: Camidy
  • Product Dimensions: 9.84 x 6.69 x 1.97 inches; 6.1 Ounces
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Camidy 1450221/120852AM102US68
  • Quality
  • Value For Money
  • Affordability

Camidy 1450221/120852AM102US68 Final Thoughts

"Thank you so much!"

Unlike the males, female Bettas should get along together. There are slats in the bottom for the babies to escape to, to keep from being eaten. I have noticed that with all they pieces in that food does not exit the bottom half. I really liked the fact I could add an airline for water flow. Mine's been doing fine and very useful. Tired of my guppies eating their fry and found this. They are now all back together, living as peaceably as fish can.

Overall Score
3.6


(3 Points)

Copyright © 2021 Rob Aquatics — Primer Child WordPress theme by GoDaddy