Editor's Choice - Our Favorite Hartz Fish Food

1. Wardley Fish Food and Accessories

User Ratings: 81 2

Hartz 4332401517 First Impressions

"I am not a fish."

My fry grow out quickly with vibrant colours. However when I opened the box one of the containers did not have a lid. My larger fish eat it just as readily as the smaller fish. Give them what they need for life and they will live happily. My neon tetras, mollies, platys, and tiger barbs love this stuff and they devour it. Beta fish response to this product is less intersted as compared to bug bites. This food seems to do better for the outside fish.

  • Wardley Fish Food and Accessories
  • Ideal protein-to-fat ratio to support healthy growth for your tropical fish
  • Includes 6.8 ounces of high-quality protein flakes in a convenient, easy-to-store jar
  • Fortified with a stabilized form of vitamin C that promotes a healthy immune system in fish
  • Contains no added dyes that can harm fish or cloud water
  • Scientifically developed
  • Formulated with fish meal, a highly digestible protein source
  • Manufacture: Wardley Products
  • Product Dimensions: 17.25 x 8.88 x 7.75 inches; 10.4 Ounces
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Hartz 4332401517
  • Quality [star rating='5']
  • Value For Money [star rating='4.2']
  • Affordability [star rating='3.9']

Hartz 4332401517 Final Thoughts

"Highly recommended!"

The flakes are easy to break up in your fingers for small little mouths if needed. My neon tetras, mollies, platys, and tiger barbs love this stuff and they devour it. My 20+ female and male bettas prefer these crisps to other foods. I bought the 7oz container which is a lot of fish food. Its a myth that petstore gold fish die after the first weekend. The container looks like the one I'd just finished so I bought it. The flakes are consistently mostly big, so it's not a big bucket of duff at all.

Overall Score
4.7

[star rating="4.7"]
(5451 Points)

Peoples Choice - Other Highly Rated Hartz Fish Food

2. Wardley Probiotic Fish & Turtle Food

User Ratings: 75 2

Hartz Goldfish Flakes with Probiotics First Impressions

"This can is HUGE!"

This might be a pro or a con, depending on the type of fish you have. The food is very nutritious and fish food isn't just fish food. Kind of seems like junk food but the fish all love it. It keeps the fish healthy and colorful. I can't use it in tanks where the majority of the fish feed at the surface. I have been using this stuff for a couple of years without a problem. I expressed my frustration at the fish store, and they recommended these granules.

  • Wardley Probiotic Fish & Turtle Food
  • Specialized tropical fish food with Probiotics scientifically developed to help maintain clear water.
  • Contains probiotics, a mixture of probiotic bacteria - 1 million live cultures per gram - that support healthy digestion, reducing waste and helping maintain clearer water.
  • Flakes are formulated with fish meal, a highly digestible protein source, for better nutrition, less waste, and cleaner water.
  • Helps bring out the brilliant color of goldfish. Contains a stabilized form of Vitamin C which supports a healthy immune system.
  • No artificial colors to stain water. Convenient, easy-to-store can.
  • Manufacture: Wardley
  • Product Dimensions: 2.79 x 2.79 x 5.3 inches; 2.2 Ounces
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Hartz Goldfish Flakes with Probiotics
  • Quality [star rating='3.8']
  • Value For Money [star rating='4.9']
  • Affordability [star rating='5']

Hartz Goldfish Flakes with Probiotics Final Thoughts

"Great price."

The Goldfish Flake is their favorite snack in the morning and evening. Best of luck to everyone and stay safe and healthy. My neon tetras, mollies, platys, and tiger barbs love this stuff and they devour it. For whatever reason, my fish have never been much attracted to pellet food. My 20+ female and male bettas prefer these crisps to other foods. I work long hours and don't always have time to feed my fish on a regular schedule. I had tried flake food in an automatic feeder which was a total disaster.

Overall Score
4.6

[star rating="4.6"]
(639 Points)

3. Hartz Wardley Advanced Nutrition Tropical Flake, 7-Ounce

User Ratings: 82 4

Hartz 4332400593 First Impressions

"Works very good."

During almost all of that time I've fed my fish TetraFin goldfish food. It feeds my pond and two tanks, happy fish! I found this TetraMin Tropical Flakes item that met all of my needs. Its a myth that petstore gold fish die after the first weekend. Doesn't cloudy my tank up, extra dissolves without any problems. Kind of seems like junk food but the fish all love it. Fish color and health are all good.

  • Hartz Wardley Advanced Nutrition Tropical Flake, 7-Ounce
  • Essential amino acids
  • Formulated to maximize protein utilization
  • Reduces fish waste
  • Made in the USA
  • Manufacture: Wardley Products
  • Item Weight: 11.8 ounces
  • Product Dimensions: 4.15 x 7.06 x 4.15 inches
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Hartz 4332400593
  • Quality [star rating='3.6']
  • Value For Money [star rating='5']
  • Affordability [star rating='3.7']

Hartz 4332400593 Final Thoughts

"Point taken."

I'd tried various flaked food, bloodworms, brine, and even live baby earthworms. The fish are always happy to eat it and they develop beautiful colors. It feeds my pond and two tanks, happy fish! The flakes inside the bucket come inside a sturdy bag. It feeds my pond and two tanks, happy fish! I'd tried various flaked food, bloodworms, brine, and even live baby earthworms. You can't beat that price anywhere else and trust me I have looked everywhere.

Overall Score
4.6

[star rating="4.6"]
(55 Points)

4. SuperClean Wardley Advanced Nutrition Perfect Protein Goldfish Food Flakes

User Ratings: 79 4

Hartz 4332400555 First Impressions

"This is great fish food."

Some feed at the surface and some feed toward the bottom of the tanks. I have been using TetraMin Tropical Flakes to feed guppies for over a dozen years. Don't hesitate, get it before you can't. I also keep the pond heater at 73 to 74 degrees all winter. The fish have grown beautifully, rich in color and very healthy. This Tetra style food doesn't do either of those things. I bought the 7oz container which is a lot of fish food.

  • SuperClean Wardley Advanced Nutrition Perfect Protein Goldfish Food Flakes
  • Fish Food Scientifically Designed To Provide The Ideal Balance Of Nutrients Your Goldfish Require To Support Normal Growth
  • Includes 3 Ounces Of Premium Flakes In A Convenient, Easy-To-Store Jar
  • Formulated For Less Waste And Cleaner Water
  • Contains No Added Artificial Dyes That Can Harm Fish Or Cloud Water
  • Scientifically Designed To Provide The Ideal Balance Of Nutrients Your Goldfish Require To Support Normal Growth
  • Manufacture: Wardley Products
  • Product Dimensions: 2.79 x 6.63 x 2.79 inches; 5.6 Ounces
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Hartz 4332400555
  • Quality [star rating='5']
  • Value For Money [star rating='4.1']
  • Affordability [star rating='4.2']

Hartz 4332400555 Final Thoughts

"They love it."

My 20+ female and male bettas prefer these crisps to other foods. In particular, they attack the red-colored flakes. If you have picky fish, the texture and flavor might be a little challenging. Our fish tell us every morning in sign language how much they like your flakes. I like how the packaging can be resealed. I have been using TetraMin Tropical Flakes to feed guppies for over a dozen years. Lesson learned, but this will work for now.

Overall Score
4.6

[star rating="4.6"]
(52 Points)

5. Seachem NutriDiet Marine Plus Flakes - Probiotic Fish Food Formula with Entice 100g

User Ratings: 69 3

Seachem 1104 First Impressions

"He didn't eat them day 1."

Some feed at the surface and some feed toward the bottom of the tanks. The flakes are easy to break up in your fingers for small little mouths if needed. They anxiously wait with signs waiting for it always. I picked a similar flake food and brought it home and tossed it in the pond. I tried a different brand for a week, and then bought a new bottle of this food. It's super fresh, and the tight seal on the lid makes its longevity stretch. It's super fresh, and the tight seal on the lid makes its longevity stretch.

  • Seachem NutriDiet Marine Plus Flakes - Probiotic Fish Food Formula with Entice 100g
  • SUPER FOOD: The Chlorella Algae contained in the NutriDiet Marine Plus Flakes are considered a potential super food that far surpasses the nutrients delivered by Spirulina Algae common to other diets. Additionally, Marine Plus Flakes are enhanced with Entice to attract finicky eaters and enhance palatability.
  • NUTRITIONAL: NutriDiet Marine Plus Flakes contain only the highest quality ingredients including fish, plankton, squid, and shrimp which are an exceptional source of a broad range of vitamins, amino acids as well as all other nutrients required for animal life.
  • VITAMIN C: The high levels of vitamin C contained in NutriDiet Marine Plus Flakes are especially important for the health of marine fish. Vitamin C is a cofactor in the process necessary for the formation of connective tissue, scar tissue in wound repair, and bone matrix.
  • PROBIOTICS: NutriDiet Marine Plus Flakes contain probiotics that help the digestive system of fish by promoting nutrient uptake, reducing waste, and supporting the immune system function.
  • FEEDING DIRECTIONS: Feed your ornamental fish as much NutriDiet Marine Plus Flakes as they will consume in three minutes of feeding at a rate of 1-3 times daily.
  • Manufacture: Seachem Laboratories, Inc.
  • Product Dimensions: 3.69 x 0.42 x 5.75 inches; 3.53 Ounces
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Seachem 1104
  • Quality [star rating='4.5']
  • Value For Money [star rating='4.7']
  • Affordability [star rating='3.4']

Seachem 1104 Final Thoughts

"I did not taste the food."

Inevitably I ran out of the flakes and went to purchase the same product. The Goldfish Flake is their favorite snack in the morning and evening. It also seems to create less waste than other brands, which keeps my tank cleaner. They keep having babies so they must be happy lol. I tried a different brand for a week, and then bought a new bottle of this food. Much better price than at the big box pet store. This food seems to do better for the outside fish.

Overall Score
4.4

[star rating="4.4"]
(57 Points)

6. Aquatic Foods Inc. S&B Blackworm & Beef Heart Mix Bit/Sticks, for Discus, Cichlids, Carnivores and M...

User Ratings: 52 12

Aquatic Foods Inc. AF-BBHMB-050 First Impressions

"But I HIGHLY RECOMMEND!"

Truth is though, my fish prefer this fish food to many others I've tried. Overall, this is a good product for a good price. I mix Tetra crisps with freeze dried Tetra blood worms. They just clean it up when I sprinkle a couple of spoonfuls. They float well, so he can play more. This is the super value tub and all my water creatures eat every bit I put in. Give them what they need for life and they will live happily.

  • Aquatic Foods Inc. S&B Blackworm & Beef Heart Mix Bit/Sticks, for Discus, Cichlids, Carnivores and More
  • Please note: All product photos are not exact, product color and sizes may vary a little
  • Ideal for All Tropical Fish, both Freshwater and Saltwater Fish
  • All Foods are packed in a Bubble Pack or a Hard Box for safe shipping
  • Some Foods may slightly vary from their Photo
  • All Aquatic Foods SINKING Bits & Sticks are extruded from our AF Flakes, they are APX. 1/8" x 3/16" to 3/8" in size. Sizes are not exact.
  • Manufacture: Aquatic Foods Inc.
  • Item Weight: 8 Ounces
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Aquatic Foods Inc. AF-BBHMB-050
  • Quality [star rating='4.9']
  • Value For Money [star rating='3.8']
  • Affordability [star rating='4.7']

Aquatic Foods Inc. AF-BBHMB-050 Final Thoughts

"Not with this stuff."

It is well worth the money especially for the size. Meaning it's overfilled for the better! Much better price than at the big box pet store. Overall a great deal, for great fish food. I also keep the pond heater at 73 to 74 degrees all winter. The Goldfish Flake is their favorite snack in the morning and evening. It feeds my pond and two tanks, happy fish!

Overall Score
3.9

[star rating="3.9"]
(77 Points)

7. Aquamax Grower 400 Starter Feed Fish Food, Extruded 3/32"(2.4mm) Pellet, 20 Ounces

User Ratings: 72 5

Aquamax First Impressions

"So it is worth the money."

I have about 11 fishes 6 different types and all fresh water fishes. This bucket of flakes allow me to feed these guys for 18 months. Its a myth that petstore gold fish die after the first weekend. Because apparently my queensland dogs like it and need to participate too. My larger fish eat it just as readily as the smaller fish. The fish are always happy to eat it and they develop beautiful colors. When I feed my fish I drop some in as is and crumple up the rest.

  • Aquamax Grower 400 Starter Feed Fish Food, Extruded 3/32"(2.4mm) Pellet, 20 Ounces
  • Carnivorous & Omnivorous Species - Trout, Bluegill, Crappie, Sunfish, Hybrid Striped Bass, Red Drum, Tilapia, Yellow Perch, Koi, Tropical Fish, Fresh Water Turtle(Juvenile), And Many More.
  • 3/32"(2.4mm) Extruded Pellet With Approximately A 50% Float Rate Appeals To Various Species At Various Growth Stages, And Helps Fingerlings Transition From Sinking To Floating Grow Out Diets.
  • 100% Nutritionally Complete And Highly Digestible For Optimum Growth And Maximum Performance. Also An Ideal Formulation For Omnivorous And Piscivorous Species That Exhibit High Protein Requirements But Do Not Beneficially Utilize Fat To Spare Protein.
  • Complete Feed for all types of Fish
  • 20oz(1.25lb) Of Feed Heat Sealed In A Resealable(zip) Mylar Stand-Up Pouch With Gas Valve.
  • Manufacture: Aquamax
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Aquamax
  • Quality [star rating='4.4']
  • Value For Money [star rating='3.6']
  • Affordability [star rating='5']

Aquamax Final Thoughts

"They love it."

For those that own fish you know how expensive it can be. Please be good to each other people. I expressed my frustration at the fish store, and they recommended these granules. They wouldn't go into detail about anything more. When I feed my fish I drop some in as is and crumple up the rest. They wouldn't go into detail about anything more. I like how the packaging can be resealed.

Overall Score
4.5

[star rating="4.5"]
(49 Points)

8. Hikari Krill Fish Food

User Ratings: 75 1

Hikari BC800310 First Impressions

"It's friken fish pellets."

It's super fresh, and the tight seal on the lid makes its longevity stretch. Nope, it is pretty big, which means my community 55-gallon tank has food for years! Overall a great deal, for great fish food. Then, fill a separate smaller container for daily use. I bought a house last year and inherited some fish in a pond. I picked a similar flake food and brought it home and tossed it in the pond. This container is a great size for the price.

  • Hikari Krill Fish Food
  • Freeze dried whole krill loaded with multi-vitamin offering superior nutrition and palatability
  • For most larger fish
  • Rich in Astaxanthin, a natural color enhancing food
  • Manufacture: 33403
  • Product Dimensions: 4 x 2.6 x 2.1 inches; 0.16 Ounces
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Hikari BC800310
  • Quality [star rating='5']
  • Value For Money [star rating='5']
  • Affordability [star rating='3.6']

Hikari BC800310 Final Thoughts

"Especially my shrimp."

Truth is though, my fish prefer this fish food to many others I've tried. I had tried flake food in an automatic feeder which was a total disaster. Florida green tree frogs, leopard frogs eat it, my southern black toads eat meat. Such an awesome value for the money! I've had backyard goldfish ponds over the last 30 years at three different homes. I can only get little one in local stores for alot more money. I have used this brand and fish food since the day I purchased my fish.

Overall Score
4.6

[star rating="4.6"]
(83 Points)

9. Tetra JumboKrill Freeze Dired Jumbo Shrimp, Vitamin Enhanced

User Ratings: 81 2

Tetra 16198 First Impressions

"Nice in water holds nice."

However when I opened the box one of the containers did not have a lid. Don't hesitate, get it before you can't. Beta fish response to this product is less intersted as compared to bug bites. Its a myth that petstore gold fish die after the first weekend. Its a myth that petstore gold fish die after the first weekend. The flakes are consistently mostly big, so it's not a big bucket of duff at all. My catfish love them, so it isn't a problem for me.

  • Tetra JumboKrill Freeze Dired Jumbo Shrimp, Vitamin Enhanced
  • aquarium DIET SUPPLEMENT Natural shrimp treat designed to supplement any Tetra staple diet foods such as TetraMin Flakes
  • FOR FRESHWATER & SALTWATER FISH Premium-quality nutritious supplement provides variety to your fish’s diet
  • AIDS DIGESTION Complete freeze-dried krill with shells are an excellent source of roughage to support digestion
  • COLOR ENHANCING Astaxanthin a natural color enhancer helps bring out the natural pink orange and red colors of fish
  • USAGE Feed 2 to 3 times a week in addition to staple diet only as much as your fish can consume within a few minutes
  • Age range description: All Ages
  • A protein-rich supplement for large tropical and marine fish
  • Manufacture: Tetra
  • Product Dimensions: 4.13 x 4.13 x 4.77 inches; 7.84 Ounces
  • Editor's Impressions Of The Tetra 16198
  • Quality [star rating='4.2']
  • Value For Money [star rating='4.7']
  • Affordability [star rating='4.7']

Tetra 16198 Final Thoughts

"He didn't eat them day 1."

Nope, it is pretty big, which means my community 55-gallon tank has food for years! I expressed my frustration at the fish store, and they recommended these granules. I have a sorority of 7 bettas, and they love this food. They didn't seem to like the stick variety so I tossed it and fed them the flakes. The flakes are easy to break up in your fingers for small little mouths if needed. Until this, the earthworms were their favorites. This is a great addition to any feeding regiment for community and betta tanks.

Overall Score
4.7

[star rating="4.7"]
(1202 Points)

10. HULX Koi Fish Food Sinking Pellets for Big Muscle & Mass Weight Gain, Whey Mixed High Protein 60% Fa...

User Ratings: 69 3

HULX First Impressions

"Fish love it."

As an avid aquarium enthusiast I use a lot of fish food. Overall a great deal, for great fish food. I STRONGLY recommend you to open the bag IN ONE CORNER with scissors. Overall, this is a good product for a good price. The flakes absorb the moisture in the air, cake up, and clog the feeder. The waste is extremely minimal to nothing. They wouldn't go into detail about anything more.

  • HULX Koi Fish Food Sinking Pellets for Big Muscle & Mass Weight Gain, Whey Mixed High Protein 60% Fast Growth Formula 1.5 Lb.(680 Gram.) 2mm, Healthy Nutrition Color Enhancer, Clear Water Pond Food
  • PROTEIN RICH FISH FOOD : High Quality Koi Food and Nutrition Whey Mixed Special High Protein 60% Fish Feed. (Can use for Goldfish too).
  • HEALHY FISH FOOD: HULX You can see the difference in just 15 days of usage. From thin Body to Fat & Big Muscle Body, Good Health, Very Fast Growth up more 2 inch (5.5 cm.) in just 30 days. It enhances the color Beautifully & make them Shine.
  • CLEAR WATER FORMULA: (**TEST RESULTS OF THE 15000+ FISH @ THAILAND FISH FARM**) HULX has Microorganism Probiotics for Good HEALTH and CLEAR water aquarium.
  • COLOR ENHANCER: Size 2 MM. HULX’s Sinking Fish Food Pellets are Insoluble in water, Promote Healthy fish, Beautiful Colors Enhancer. Do not cause waste or sediment in water and improves the quality of water for longer duration.
  • FAST GROWTH: Feed 2-4 times daily with HULX (FAST BIG BODY, BIG MUSCLE & MORE FAT)
  • Manufacture: HULX
  • Product Dimensions: 7 x 2.75 x 10 inches; 1.37 Pounds
  • Editor's Impressions Of The HULX
  • Quality [star rating='3.8']
  • Value For Money [star rating='3.7']
  • Affordability [star rating='5']

HULX Final Thoughts

"Good stuff."

It's a peaceful scene those pretty fish enjoying their snack. I actually only buy their food and fish tank kits. It keeps the fish healthy and colorful. They just clean it up when I sprinkle a couple of spoonfuls. LoL, So we are all happy at meal time. This is the super value tub and all my water creatures eat every bit I put in. However when I opened the box one of the containers did not have a lid.

Overall Score
4.4

[star rating="4.4"]
(66 Points)

Copyright © 2024 Rob Aquatics — Primer Child WordPress theme by GoDaddy